Study & Essay
Study Questions
Discuss the roots of Gandhi's personal
philosophy.
Gandhi was not a rigorist, and his philosophy
of life was more of a loose collection of ideas that a strict structure
of thought. The initial and most profound influences on his thinking
were the Bhagavad-Gita and Christ's Sermon on
the Mount, both of which he read while in England in 1888-91.
From the former, one of the greatest works of religious poetry in
Hinduism, Gandhi encountered the idea that renunciation and "desirelessness"
were the key to human happiness and goodness, since only when one
set aside one's own desire could one truly work for the good of
others. The Sermon on the Mount offered similar notions, while
also celebrating and embracing the meek and the poor– notions that
would later have a hand in motivating Gandhi's later work among
the lowest classes of India. The third pillar of Gandhi's thought
was the somewhat more obscure work Unto This Last,
by the British author and critic John Ruskin, which he read around
1904-5. This book led him to his conviction that physical labor
was morally superior to other forms of work, and instilled in him
a lifelong distaste for modernity and a preference for the traditional
ways of life in India.
Why was satyagraha so
successful against the British?
Satyagraha translates literally
as "soul force," and the word "soul" seems to refer to both sides
in the struggle. For the practitioners of satyagraha, who
practiced civil disobedience all across India under Gandhi's direction,
"soul" meant courage–the courage to accept arrest and punishment
without giving in. Thus by rendering threats and intimidation
ineffective, "soul-force" could literally bring the Raj to grinding
a halt: no one could be forced to work. But "soul force"
drew its effectiveness not only from the strength of the Indian
people's souls, or courage; it also appealed to the souls, or consciences,
of the British rulers. The British, after all, were idealists
too–they believed, at least officially, in the ideas of liberty
and equality. Thus they had difficulty punishing unresisting,
agreeable, even seemingly cheerful Indians. By drawing upon great
"soul force," or courage, and confronting the British with non-violent resistance,
Gandhi's Indians were able to speak to the souls, or ideals, of
their oppressors, and make their adversaries their friends.
Why did Gandhi turn against the British
Empire?
Peculiar as it may seem to us in light of
his later career, Gandhi was initially an ardent British patriot.
He truly believed that British rule had benefited India by bringing
the ideals of the British Constitution–liberty, order, equality
before the law–to the subcontinent. And while he hoped that Indians
would eventually achieve some form of home rule, he maintained
his loyalty to the British Crown up until the very end of World
War I, during which he actually worked to recruit Indians for the
British army. His mind began to change with the passage of the
Rowlatt Act of 1918, which cracked down on civil liberties in post-war
India–freedom of the speech, assembly, the press, etc. The British
passed the Rowlatt Act in order to prevent unrest in the Raj, but
for Gandhi, the Act was a betrayal of the Empire's ideals. He
began to ask: If the Empire did not provide equality and liberty
for Indians, then what did it stand for? He began taking the position
of the pro-independence camp, and his new stance was cemented by
the Amritsar Massacre of April 13, 1919, when British troops under
Brigadier-General Dyer gunned down a huge crowd of unarmed Indians.
For Gandhi, as for many Indians, this was the breaking point; after
the massacre, the British were never to be trusted again.
Essay Topics
Was Gandhi primarily a political figure, or a social
reformer? Defend your answer.
Why was India partitioned in 1947? Discuss Gandhi's
attitude toward, and role in, the partition.
Compare and contrast Gandhi's careers in India and South
Africa.
Discuss Gandhi's decision to become celibate, to adopt Brahmacharya.
How was this consistent with his political philosophy?
Discuss Gandhi's relationship with the untouchables.
What role did this caste play in his vision of India's future?
Analyze the relationship between Gandhi and the Indian
people. What was the significance of the term Mahatma in this context?
What was the legacy of Gandhi's efforts in India? How
did the Indian independence movement influence future independence
movements in other countries? How did it help to end colonialism
and change global power structures? In particular, how did Gandhi's
methods of non-violent protest influence future social and political
movements?