Across Five Aprils
The book begins as Ellen Creighton and her nine-year-old son, Jethro, plant potatoes for the summer crop. Ellen has had twelve children, four of whom have died. She is a tired woman who favors Jethro most of all. Three of Jethro's siblings died from children's paralysis the year Jethro was born, but Jethro managed to escape the disease. Ellen knows he is special, "as if, somehow, Destiny had marked him." They break to say goodbye to Shadrach Yale, Jethro's teacher who, upon not having enough money to continue his studies, began teaching at the school where Matt Creighton, Jethro's father, worked. Ellen had nursed Shadrach back to health after he contracted typhoid fever, and Shadrach is now part of the family—especially to Jethro's sister Jenny, who has been in love with Shadrach for some time.
Shadrach is planning to leave to go to a neighboring town to receive news about the dispute between the North and the South. Ellen worries that he will bring back news of war. As they are working in the field, Jethro tries to distract his mother by telling her about Copernicus, but he knows that nothing can make her forget about the troubles. Talk of Abraham Lincoln's election, issues of tariffs, free states, slave states, and rebellion have gotten so heated that war seems imminent. Jethro kind of looks forward to the war, because "war meant loud brass music and shining horses ridden by men wearing uniforms . "
Thinking of war prompts Jethro to think about his sister Mary's death. A group of hoodlums broke up a dance she was attending and chased Mary and her date. One of the hoodlums, Travis Burdow, fired a pistol that frightened the horses, causing the wagon to overturn and kill Mary. The town banded together to seek revenge on Travis Burdow—the whole Burdow family had been hoodlums—but Matt Creighton had called an end to it. Jethro feels the same about Lincoln as he did about his father then: "They had not shown the hard, unyielding attitude that he admired . " Ellen explains that Lincoln has to make a choice when there seems only two wrong choices to make.
Nancy, Jethro's brother John's wife, and Jenny prepare dinner, and the family all sits down to eat. The whole family including Bill and Tom, Jethro's brothers, and Eb, Jethro's cousin, are there. Jenny and Bill are Jethro's favorites, even though Bill sometimes seems strange and quiet, preferring a book to anyone's company. At the table they talk about Jenny's affection for Shadrach, which Matt Creighton promptly discourages, saying she is too young.
Jethro and his mother return to the field. As they stop to rest, they see a team of horses coming up the road. It is Wilse Graham, Ellen's sister's son, visiting from Kentucky. They anxiously await what news he brings.
Wilse brings Ellen up to date on her Kentucky family. Matt asks Wilse if Kentucky wants to secede, and Wilse says maybe and, in return, asks how southern Illinois would feel about it. Matt says it will be hard for the river states, and Wilse argues that southern Illinois is part of the South. Matt argues that "separate, we're jest two weakened, puny pieces, each needin' the other." Wilse argues that only half of the country enjoys those benefits. Wilse says that the South should be able to do what it wants with no interference and adds that since the beginning of time slavery has existed. Wilse says that the real issue is greed, not slavery. Jethro listens to this conversation and realizes that any excitement he felt about the prospect of war was immature.
Ellen calls for the arguing to stop, and Wilse apologizes. Jethro naps on the porch and wakes up when Shadrach returns. Shadrach reports that there has been firing at Fort Sumter and that after thirty hours, the Union general surrendered. Jenny asks if this means war, and Shadrach explains that since Congress is not in session and cannot declare war, it technically is not war yet. However, Lincoln had asked for 75,000 volunteers to fight. Matt says that despite Congress not being in session, it is indeed war.
These chapters depict the beginning of two slow transformations. First, it introduces the transformation of years of malcontent and animosity between regions of the nation into a full-fledged war. And second, the chapters illustrate the deterioration of Jethro's family from a single unit into one picked bare by the war and, by consequence, Jethro's transformation from a boy into a man during a time of war.
Chapter 2 in particular sets up the arguments between the North and the South. Hunt shows us how the arguments play out, as the discussion prompted by Wilse Graham's visit typifies the arguments of the day. This discussion underscores Ellen's comment that Lincoln has to pick between two wrong choices—even though it might be the reader's tendency to agree with position of the North, if only for anti-slavery reasons, the arguments from both sides are convincing—neither side is entirely wrong and neither is entirely right. The fact that a relative of Ellen's sides with the South shows how common it is for not only the country, but for families, friends, and small communities as well, to be divided on this issue. Hunt uses Wilse Graham to foreshadow all the families that will be pulled apart by disagreements regarding the war.
In Chapter 2, Jethro has an insight into what war means. As a boy it is understandable that he associates war with fanfare and shining patriotism. He soon realizes—a realization that becomes deeper and graver as the book proceeds—that war is neither a show nor a game. He begins to understand just how serious war is if it brings a family to boiling arguments at the dinner table. Shadrach's news that shots have been fired and that the Union general has surrendered drives home two points: that the war has indeed begun and that the North is in for a tough fight.
In a sense, Chapters 1 and 2 are a small-scale version of the book in its entirety. Hunt gives us a sense of who the characters are and what roles they fill in the context of the family. From here on out, we see those characters function not so much within the context of family but within the context of war, which means they struggle to keep the family intact. The realizations they have in the beginning of the text sink in deeper and deeper—for some characters, they become physical, every day realizations and for others they remain topics for mind dwelling and brooding. For everyone, these realizations of war bring fear and uncertainty. At the end of Chapter 2, as they gather around Shadrach for the news, it is the last time they are all together as a family. The end of Chapter 2 is the brink, and none of the characters is the same from this point on.
Readers' Notes allow users to add their own analysis and insights to our SparkNotes—and to discuss those ideas with one another. Have a novel take or think we left something out? Add a Readers' Note!