Study Questions & Essay Topics
Study Questions
1. How does Homer
portray the relationship between gods and men in the Odyssey? What
roles do the gods play in human life? How does this portrayal differ
from that found in the Iliad?
In the Iliad, the gods relate
to human beings either as external powers that influence the lives
of mortals from without, as when Apollo unleashes plague upon the
Achaeans, or from within, as when Aphrodite incites Helen to make
love to Paris or when Athena gives Diomedes courage in battle. In
the Odyssey, the gods are often much less grand.
They function more as spiritual guides and supporters for their
human subjects, sometimes assuming mortal disguises in order to
do so. The actions of the gods sometimes remain otherworldly, as
when Poseidon decides to wreck the ship of the Phaeacians, but generally
they grant direct aid to particular individuals. In a sense, the
change in the behavior of the gods is wholly appropriate to the
shift in focus between the two epics. The Iliad depicts
a violent and glorious war, and the gods act as frighteningly powerful,
supernatural forces. The Odyssey, in contrast,
chronicles a long journey, and the gods frequently act to guide
and advise the wandering hero.
2. In what ways
does Odysseus develop as a character during the course of the narrative?
Does he develop at all?
Odysseus does not change remarkably during
the course of the narrative, especially in comparison to Telemachus,
who undergoes a rite of passage from naive adolescence to manhood.
Odysseus, already a famed soldier at the beginning of the Iliad, continues
his role as the most intelligent and courageous of all the Achaean heroes.
But this is not to say that Odysseus exhibits no signs of growth.
Just as Achilles is confronted in the Iliad with
the problem of balancing his honor with his pride, Odysseus repeatedly
faces situations in which self-restraint and humility must check
bravado and glory-seeking. In his early adventures, he often fails
these tests, as when he boastfully taunts Polyphemus, enflaming
Poseidon.
As the epic progresses, Odysseus becomes increasingly
capable of judging when it is wise to reveal himself and when it
is appropriate to exult in his accomplishments. At Scheria, he prudently
waits until late in his visit before declaring his identity to the
king and queen. By the time he reaches Ithaca, he can endure the
insults of the suitors for the better part of two days. The ability
to hold his passions and pride in check make his swift and total
revenge upon the suitors possible. Odysseus’s internal conflict
is not nearly as consuming as that of Achilles in the Iliad, making
up a relatively small part of his overall journey, but he too is
a wiser and stronger man at the end of his epic.
3. One of the
most important cultural values in the Odyssey is
that of xenia, a Greek concept encompassing the generosity and courtesy
shown to those who are far from home. Why might hospitality have
held more significance in Homer’s time than it does in today’s world?
How is hospitality established as a key value in the epic?
Odysseus’s journey takes place in a world
in which vast swaths of uninhabited land separate human civilizations.
Traveling between those settlements involves facing both natural
and supernatural perils, as well as logistical problems like shortages
in provisions. The code of hospitality operates as a linchpin that
allows individuals such as Odysseus to undertake these kinds of
journeys at all. It is a set of reciprocal expectations and obligations
that not only mitigate the privations of travel but forge and reinforce
bonds of friendship and goodwill. Not surprisingly, the Odyssey doles
out harsh punishments to those who do not respect this sacred social
code. Polyphemus, the suitors, and the Achaean soldiers at Ismarus
all suffer for violating it. By the same token, individuals such
as Eumaeus and the Phaeacian royalty prove their worth to Odysseus
by showering him with selfless generosity and kindness. Within the Odyssey, adherence
to the code functions as a kind of imperfect currency. If one acts in
accordance with the rules, one will generally, but not always, be rewarded.
Suggested Essay Topics
1. What is the role of family
in the Odyssey? What values characterize the relationship
between fathers and sons? You may wish to compare and contrast some
of the father and son pairs in the epic (Odysseus and Telemachus,
Laertes and Odysseus, Poseidon and Polyphemus, Nestor and Pisistratus, Eupithes
and Antinous). How does Homer portray the idea of continuity between
generations?
2. What is the role of women
in the Odyssey? Focusing especially on Penelope,
Calypso, or Anticleia, discuss how women are portrayed in this epic.
3. Compare and contrast Telemachus’s
journey with that of Odysseus. How does the younger man’s experience
enable him to grow as a character? What role does Athena play in
his success?
4. Looking at Odysseus’s narrative
in Books 9 through 12,
think about the techniques Homer uses to portray the magical and fantastical
aspects of Odysseus’s adventures. How does he handle what we might
call special effects? That is, how does he make his monsters fearsome,
his goddesses stunning, the dangers frightening, etc.?