I used a black gel liner on the top, and a black waterproof pencil on the bottom waterline. Using a liquid or gel liner to create a clean black line will help to hide the false lash band later. Yes, you read that right; I’m using false lashes in this look. YES, YES I KNOW. I’ve expressed my mixed feelings about falsies before, but looking at that picture of Taylor, I don’t think there’s any way we could make it through this tutorial without them.