Vampire Diaries (CW)
True story—I ignored TVD as a Twilight clone for years, until I wrote an article for this blog asking if I should give it a try. The general consensus was that I should (which, of course, I did). Now I've seen every episode and will gladly defend it as one of the most consistent and enjoyable genre shows running. Thanks Masterminds, you helped me overcome my prejudice and discover a really fun show.