Now, I’ll venture a guess and say that werewolf hunters don’t get much sleep, so dark eyes seem the natural way to go. Also, I don’t think you get attacked like this without coming out with a black eye, or in this case, two black eyes. I couldn’t find my black MAC Paint Pot, so I used a NYX Gel Eyeliner all over the lid. It worked fine, but I think I would have preferred the Paint Pot. Using a q-tip, I smudged more of the liner underneath my eyes.