Search Menu

On Liberty

John Stuart Mill

Contents

Chapter 2, Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion (Part 2)

page 3 of 3

Chapter 2, Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion (Part 2)

Chapter 2, Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion (Part 2)

Chapter 2, Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion (Part 2)

Chapter 2, Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion (Part 2)

Chapter 2, Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion (Part 2)

Finally, it is also worth looking at Mill's refutation of someone who thinks that Christianity is the whole truth. Mill seems to argue that such a person misinterprets Christianity. Would this response be convincing to a person with views on Christianity that are different from Mill's? Does Mill have other arguments that might provide a better response to this claim? More generally, Mill's discussion of religious toleration in Chapter 2 brings up the issue of whether Mill can be convincing to people whose beliefs demand intolerance of those who disagree with them. Since Mill is using social benefit as the basis of his justification for liberty, it would seem that a person who believes in intolerance could simply say that any benefits of free opinion are outweighed by allowing something evil to be expressed. Think about how persuasive such a critique is, given Mill's claims about the need for dissent in order to truly understand one's own opinions.

More Help

Previous Next
Mill & Truth

by JustMeandMyBalls, December 06, 2013

In the last paragraph of the commentary there is a discussion of Mill's belief in the existence of truth. It is my opinion that the way this last paragraph was written does not adequately represent Mill's understanding of truth. The commentator confuses moral truth and utilitarian truth. The commentary assumes truth on the basis of simple right or wrong, but Mill was a utilitarian. I believe Mill's understanding of truth is one where the 'trueness' of an idea is weighed by its ability to serve the greater good. (The effectual utility that th... Read more

0 Comments

88 out of 92 people found this helpful

To the gentleman with the balls

by Jilani-Sparknotes-Writer, November 19, 2016

Oh ok my bad.

0 Comments

1 out of 1 people found this helpful

To the gentleman with the balls

by Jilani-Sparknotes-Writer, November 19, 2016

I guess you're right, my bad.

See all 4 readers' notes   →