Modifiers and Modification
A modifier is a word or a phrase
that describes another word or phrase. The most familiar examples
are adjectives and adverbs. Adjectives
describe nouns or pronouns. Adverbs describe verbs, adjectives,
or other adverbs. (Articles—the, a, an—are
also considered adjectives by some authorities.)
Here are some examples:
Adjectives
The dark night hid all.
The harmful rays of the sun penetrated
the skin.
Adverbs
Laurie ran quickly.
Ziki spoke French fluently. |
The SAT often tests whether an adjective or an adverb
is required. For example, why is the following sentence incorrect?
My dog smelled terrible before
his bath. |
Terrible is an adjective modifying smelled,
which is a verb. That’s a no-no; it should be:
My dog smelled terribly before
his bath. |
In addition to testing whether a sentence needs an adverb
or an adjective, the SAT will very likely test whether you use the
proper form of an adjective. Adjectives can take three forms:
| Descriptive |
Comparative |
Superlative |
| sharp |
sharper |
sharpest |
| cold |
colder |
coldest |
| fascinating |
more fascinating |
most fascinating |
| good |
better |
best |
| bad |
worse |
worst |
Most adjectives follow the regular forms exemplified by sharp and cold. Some,
like fascinating, require more for
the comparative and most for the superlative. Good and bad,
and some others, are irregular.
Consider the following sentences:
Of the three knives, that one
is sharper.
That knife is sharpest than this one. |
Both are incorrect. The comparative form should
be used with two objects; the superlative with three or more objects.
The sentences should be:
Of the three knives, that one
is sharpest.
That knife is sharper than this one. |
Phrases can act as modifiers, too, and this is where things
get a little trickier:
Racing down the country road,
Carlos felt rejuvenated by the crisp morning air. |
The phrase racing down the country road is
a unit that modifies Carlos. But what if we wrote
the sentence another way?
Racing down the country road,
the crisp morning air rejuvenated Carlos. |
What this second sentence is saying is that the
crisp morning air was racing down the country road as
it rejuvenated Carlos. This is the storied dangling
modifier. The modifier racing down the country road dangles
off the front of the sentence, unconnected to Carlos,
the word it modifies. You will likely see a bunch of these
on the test—the SAT loves to test this concept. Some
other examples of dangling modifiers follow; they can be pretty
funny once you recognize the error:
- Incorrect
Smoking a big cigar, the baby was admired by its father.
- Comment
There’s very little chance that any baby would be
precocious enough to smoke a cigar.
- Correct
Smoking a big cigar, the father admired his baby.
- Incorrect
Sweating profusely from the exertion, there are some drawbacks
to cycling in the summer.
- Comment
This modifier is dangling by a thread—what could sweating profusely
from the exertion modify in this sentence?
- Correct
One of the drawbacks of summer cycling is that you’ll
sweat profusely.
- Incorrect
Sweating profusely from the exertion, my shirt was
soaked in five minutes.
- Comment
Was the shirt doing the sweating?
I think not!
- Correct
Sweating profusely from the exertion, I soaked my
shirt in five minutes.
- Incorrect
To stave off dehydration, a lot of water should be
drunk while biking.
- Comment
We’re missing the noun that needs modification—who needs to
stave off dehydration?
- Correct
To stave off dehydration, bikers should drink a lot
of water.
Here’s an example of another error that shows
up a lot on the SAT: the misplaced modifier. Typically,
adverbs are to blame for this very common mistake:
He nearly hit that ball out
of the park. |
What’s wrong with that, you ask? The golden rule of modification,
as you may have guessed, is: Keep the modifier as close to
what it modifies as possible. That’s exactly what the author
of this sentence did: nearly modifies the verb hit.
OK, so what’s the problem? Well, sometimes this rule is broken for
the sake of clarity and logic. What, exactly, does it mean to nearly
hit something? Isn’t that kind of like missing it?
That’s not what happened, clearly, so fix the sentence like so:
He hit that ball nearly out
of the park. |
Now what happened is crystal clear: the batter hit the
ball and almost knocked it out of the park.