The story also introduces a number of close parallels
between Holgrave and the Maule family that have been largely dormant
until now. Like Holgrave, the younger Matthew Maule is an artist,
and though he is a tradesman by profession, Alice is primarily struck
by the artistry evident in Maule’s craft. Even more obviously, Holgrave shows
the same hypnotic capabilities as the younger Maule, and he ends
his story in much the same state as his protagonist does when his
spell is over, elated that his subject is now under his spell. Although
Maule clearly does not have Gervayse’s best intentions in mind when
he casts his spell, he is pleasantly surprised by the power he has
over Alice, and his ultimate grief over her death suggests he is not
fully aware of the extent of his power. Holgrave’s intentions appear
to be purer, but he too is not entirely aware of his abilities. Though
he is tempted by the fact that Phoebe has fallen under his spell,
it does not appear to be his goal in telling the story. It is important
that Holgrave does not follow through on his newfound power—his
connection to the Maules remains murky, but he seems to be exercising
the willpower necessary to break family patterns.
