After Paris and Joan's failed siege of La Charite-sur-Loire, Joan's career went rapidly downhill, though in December of 1429 the thankful King Charles VII promoted Joan, her parents, and her brothers to noble status. In 1430, the Duke of Burgundy threatened Champagne and Brie, and Joan promised Charles she would protect the regions. Thus, she left Charles's side to fight the Burgundian forces at the ill-fated Battle of Compiegne. Joan was accompanied only by her brother Pierre, her squire Jean de Aulon, and a few soldiers. Nonetheless, when she reached Compiegne on May 14, 1430, Joan's very presence helped greatly to rally the people there, giving them new hope against the Burgundian threat. Joan then accompanied Renaud, the archbishop of Reims, southward before returning to Compiegne.
Upon her return, Joan was surprised to find the city under siege from a leader allied with England, John of Luxembourg. Luxembourg was the Duke of Burgundy's most capable captain, so Joan was up against a formidable opponent. Joan managed to sneak into the city secretly, past John's guards, and led several brave attempts to repel the Burgundian forces. Totally outmanned, the city of Compiegne fell to John of Luxembourg's army. Joan led forces to hold off John's soldiers while the citizens escaped. In the process, Luxembourg's men captured Joan, an even more valuable prize than the city itself: Joan had found her army's escape route cut off by the British army, which had lain in waiting, and as the French made a final attempt to flee, an archer pulled Joan off her horse and onto the ground. After her capture, Joan immediately swore to her captors that she would do nothing that would betray Charles VII.
Archbishop Renaud, a clergyman on Charles's side, told everyone that Joan's capture was her own fault, and that ignoring Charles's orders had gotten her into her present crisis: and indeed, Charles had been thinking of surrendering Compiegne to the Duke of Burgundy anyway in hopes of appeasing him. But the people of Compiegne had refused to give up and be ruled by Burgundy; thus Joan wasn't the one who had disobeyed orders; she had merely aided a town that, out of loyalty to the king and France, was unwilling to abide by Charles's wishes. Ultimately, Compiegne's loyalty to France so offended the Duke of Burgundy that he became even closer with his English allies.
The failure to take Paris had marked the beginning of Joan's downfall. Her luck now continued to go downhill, and she would win no more battles. Still, the common people always rallied under her banner. Indeed, in Campiegne she proved her devotion to the people of France by standing boldly against the British in order to allow the people of the city to make their escape. Charles was increasingly frightened by her immense popularity with the people, who were already venerating her as a saint. Charles's advisors had turned against Joan a long time before; now the King himself began to think he would be better off without her interference. Joan, now given a fully independent command, proved unable to win victory at Compiegne, and her strategy was disorganized and wavering. This showed that, although an extremely valuable asset to the French military in terms of her ability to boost morale, as a lone commander she was not militarily gifted–or even all that militarily competent. This was not surprising, given that she had no formal training in the art of war, nor any real experience. Joan made several bad decisions at Compiegne, including marching hr troops through the night to get there. Exhausted, the troops wanted to rest upon arrival, but Joan only gave them a few hours before beginning an attack against John of Luxembourg's forces. Thus the contest was doomed from the start, for the enemy not only had more energy, but they also had more men. Some have pointed out that the first attack did take the Burgundians by surprise, and thus represented some good strategy. However, the immediate attack did not turn the tide of the battle against the British and it was extremely hard on Joan's troops, who had little fight left in them after the first engagements.
According to legend, before the Battle of Compiegne Joan started making predictions that her end was near. Although this may very well be an embellishment added to the story for dramatic effect, perhaps Joan did sense that, with her men ever less motivated and Charles increasingly against her, she could not maintain her privileged position much longer.
At the time, when an army captured anyone as important as Joan, they would ransom the person. Joan, however, was a special case, and was not ransomed. Joan hoped she would die quickly, because she greatly feared torture and imprisonment, especially a long imprisonment. Some stories say that when she was captured, she pretended to be a man until she was found out. This story is unlikely. Joan's crest was well known and she dressed in very colorful, fine clothing. She was not hard to pick out in a crowd and her description was now famous throughout France. Burgundy was extremely excited by Joan's capture, and he immediately wrote a letter to commemorate his success. Very soon, the clergy at the University of Paris (remember, Paris was then mostly pro-English) let it be known that they wished to interrogate Joan, whom English propaganda had long associated with witchcraft.
Joanne, it seems, was of royal family. Cardinal Mazarini used to say, that official story of Joanne is a pile of crap. And it looks like it.
Voices, miracles, praying right and left, confessing wounded English, peasant parents, virgin of 19 year old in Middle Ages... What a pile of crap.
Joanne wore full knight armor. She handled f battle horse. She slept in armor near campfires. She handled weapons and participated in tournaments. She knew how Dauphin looked like. She had a coat of arms with royal insignia. - All these facts a... Read more→
8 out of 40 people found this helpful
Just read Zakaton's comment re: Joan of Arc. His opinion is one wherein he has clearly begun with a judgement of Joan before referring to the facts.
Joan of Arc was born into a peasant family on the fringes of French held territory in what is now known as the Vosges department in North West France. Joan's village itself also felt the violence of the 100 Years War. Domremy suffered from an English attack in 1426 and her family was forced to take shelter in a nearby town. She was a simple child of deep religious faith, even exceptional, ... Read more→
12 out of 13 people found this helpful
Take a Study Break!