Types of Natural Selection
Natural selection can take many forms. To make talking about this easier, we
will consider the distribution of traits across a population in graphical
form. In we see the normal bell curve of trait
distribution. For example, if we were talking about height as a trait, we would
see that without any selection pressure on this trait, the heights of
individuals in a population would vary, with most individuals being of an
average height and fewer being extremely short or extremely tall. However, when
selection pressures act on a trait, this distribution can be altered.
Figure1.1: The standard distribution of a trait across a population
Stabilizing selection
When selective pressures select against the two extremes of a trait, the
population experiences stabilizing selection. For example, plant height
might be acted on by stabilizing selection. A plant that is too short may not
be able to compete with other plants for sunlight. However, extremely tall
plants may be more susceptible to wind damage. Combined, these two selection
pressures select to maintain plants of medium height. The number of plants of
medium height will increase while the numbers of short and tall plants will
decrease.
Figure1.2: The effect of stabilizing selection on trait distribution
Directional selection
In directional selection, one extreme of the trait distribution experiences
selection against it. The result is that the population's trait distribution shifts
toward the other extreme. In the case of such selection, the mean of the population
graph shifts. Using the familiar example of giraffe necks, there was a selection
pressure against short necks, since individuals with short necks could not reach
as many leaves on which to feed. As a result, the distribution of neck length
shifted to favor individuals with long necks.
Figure1.3: The effect of directional selection on trait distribution
Disruptive Selection
In disruptive selection, selection pressures act against individuals in the
middle of the trait distribution. The result is a bimodal, or two-peaked, curve
in which the two extremes of the curve create their own smaller curves. For
example, imagine a plant of extremely variable height that is pollinated by
three different pollinators, one that was attracted to short plants, another
that preferred plants of medium height and a third that visited only the tallest
plants. If the pollinator that preferred plants of medium height disappeared
from an area, medium height plants would be selected against and the population
would tend toward both short and tall, but not medium height plants. Such a
population, in which multiple distinct forms or morphs exist is said to be
polymorphic.
Figure1.4: The effect of disruptive selection on trait distribution