The Genetic Perspective: Addictive Inheritance
Whether genetics contribute to addiction is controversial and is a
derivative of the debated topic of whether genes contribute to behavior at all.
The genetic basis for states such as schizophrenia and manic-depression
is currently a topic of wide investigation. The behaviors that accompany these
states and others appear to be influence both by genetic and environmental
factors. It is neither nature nor nurture alone, rather nature and
nurture that influence behavior. Such is also considered to be the case with
addictive behavior, and has been most thoroughly investigated in cases of
alcohol and tobacco.
There are several methods used to study the influence of genetics on behavior.
They are family studies, adoption studies, twin studies, twins-reared-apart and animal studies. Through these various kinds of genetic
studies, various results have implied that genes do play a role in addiction,
most specifically to alcohol and tobacco. This being the case, it is likely
that all behaviors are influenced to some degree by genetics, including
addiction.
Family studies have shown that the incidence of alcoholism is increased in
families where one or more members of the family have been diagnosed with
alcoholism. Studies have indicated that the progeny of an alcoholic mother or
father have two to four times the probability of becoming alcoholic than does
the general population. Although little has been done to show that smoking is
influenced by genetics, it is a fact that children of smoking parents are more
likely to smoke. How much of this is also an environmental issue is not clear.
Adoption studies have also drawn conclusions that alcohol addiction is genetic.
Groups of males that had biological but not adoptive parents that were
alcoholics were compared to a group of men that had biological and adoptive
parents that were not alcoholics. The former group showed an increased
incidence for alcoholism four times greater than the latter. A later study
(Goodwin et al., 1974) compared the incidence of alcoholism in adopted-away sons
of alcoholics with their biological brothers who had been raised by the
alcoholic parents. The incidence of alcoholism was identical. The work of
Goodwin (1979) also demonstrated that genetic factors are not as important in
determining alcoholism in females.
Twin studies and twins-reared-apart studies are the most powerful tools for
evaluating genetic affects on behavior. Unfortunately, few of these studies
have been used in alcohol related research. The data that has been generated,
though, does support the notion that alcohol addiction is influence by genetic
factors. In comparing monozygotic (identical) and dizygotic (fraternal) twins,
there are different outcomes. Although twins of either category are associated
with higher incidences of alcoholism, those of the monozygotic type have an even
greater rate.
Animal studies have been used extensively to evaluate the genetic contributions
to alcohol and nicotine addiction. Studies by Collins (1979) showed that
genetics influence preference for and initial sensitivity to the severity of
withdrawal from alcohol. Further investigations have indicated that both
metabolism of and central nervous system sensitivities to alcohol are influenced
by genetic factors. Similar conclusions have been drawn with nicotine. Mice
studies conducted by Marks et al. (1983) showed that these nervous system
sensitivities probably involve different brain receptors specific for nicotine.
These receptors play a role in the degree of response the individual will get
from the drug.
The degree to which genetic factors play a role in addictive behavior is still
unclear and remains to be further investigated. The data do suggest that with
alcohol, and to a lesser extent nicotine, genetic factors influence addiction
considerably. Neither is influenced solely by genetics and environmental
conditions appear to be notably important. An area of research that will
further define the roles will be to study the affects of environmental factors
on genetically susceptible people. The biochemical approach to understanding
addiction is another area where genes may contribution.