|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
Chapter 17
Summary
After all, to the well-organized mind, death is but the next great adventure. Harry lies, telling Quirrell that he sees himself in
the mirror winning the house cup for Gryffindor. Voldemort tells
Quirrell that Harry is lying. Wishing to speak directly to Harry
now, Voldemort tells Quirrell to unwrap his turban. Harry is shocked
to find Voldemort’s face on the back of Quirrell’s head—Voldemort
is a shape-shifter and has been using Quirrell’s body. Voldemort
tries to persuade Harry to give him the stone, which he knows is
in Harry’s pocket. He tells Harry to join him rather than resist
and be killed like his parents. Harry refuses and Voldemort orders
Quirrell to seize Harry. Quirrell tries, but each time he grabs
for Harry, his hand blisters as if burned. Harry grabs Quirrell,
putting him in tremendous pain; meanwhile, the pain in Harry’s forehead
scar is steadily increasing. As the struggle intensifies, Harry
feels himself losing hold of Quirrell and falling.
When Harry regains consciousness, Dumbledore is standing over
him. Harry starts telling Dumbledore that Quirrell has the stone,
but Dumbledore tells him to relax. Harry realizes that he is in the
hospital. He asks Dumbledore again about the stone and Dumbledore
tells him that he arrived just in time to save Harry from Quirrell.
Dumbledore adds that he spoke with Nicolas Flamel and they decided
to destroy the stone. He explains also that Quirrell could not touch
Harry because Harry was protected by his mother’s love. Dumbledore
also reveals that it was he who left the invisibility cloak for
Harry and explains that there was enmity between Snape and Harry’s
father, much like the enmity between Malfoy and Harry. Furthermore,
Dumbledore explains how Harry ended up with the stone; Harry was
the only one who wanted to find the stone for itself rather than
for what the stone could obtain.
Harry gets out of his hospital bed to go to the end-of-year
feast. The dining hall is decorated in Slytherin colors to celebrate Slytherin’s
seventh consecutive win of the championship cup. Dumbledore rises
to speak and announces that in light of recent events, more points
need to be given out. He awards Ron and Hermione fifty points each
and Harry sixty points for their feats in getting to the stone.
Gryffindor thus pulls into a tie with Slytherin. Dumbledore then
adds that Neville has been awarded ten points for learning bravery.
Gryffindor pulls ahead into first place, thus winning the house
cup.
When school grades finally arrive, Harry and Ron do well,
and Hermione is at the top of the class. They all pack and head
to the train station to go back to their homes. Harry, Hermione,
and Ron say their good-byes for the summer and Harry heads home,
eager to use a little magic on Dudley Dursley. Analysis
Quirrell’s comment about the Sorcerer’s Stone and his
affections for Voldemort that “[t]here is no good and evil, there
is only power and those too weak to see it” evoke important philosophical
ideas. The sentiments Quirrell expresses underlie one of the classic
works of political theory, Niccolò Machiavelli’s The Prince. In
this sixteenth-century work Machiavelli wrote about how rulers should
expand their power with no regard for morality or justice. The distinction Quirrell
makes here between “power” and “those too weak to see it” follows
the principles that Machiavelli laid out. Quirrell’s statement also
echoes the thought of nineteenth-century German philosopher Friedrich
Nietzsche, who argued that individual human will and striving are
more important and relevant than morality and more impressive than
flimsy notions of right and wrong. The ideas of these two philosophers
emphasize the individual at the expense of the common good, and
Voldemort embodies their values.
By placing these sentiments in the mouth of Quirrell,
who is as pathetic and squirrelly as his name suggests, Rowling
rejects the idea that the world should be based on power and domination
of others. It is fine to cultivate power; Dumbledore’s power, after
all, is exceptional and praiseworthy. But the story suggests that
with power comes responsibility toward others and that responsibility includes
a sense of what is right and wrong. Dumbledore shows the students
that Slytherin House may have acquired a lot of points but that
victory should go to the house that has been engaged in a just and
righteous struggle. This is surely also the reason that Flamel is induced
to destroy the Sorcerer’s Stone; it is a source of incredible power,
but there is no guarantee that its power will be used properly, and
so it must be destroyed. Power is important, but morality is more
so.
The wisdom of limiting one’s desires is revealed at the
end, when Dumbledore tells Harry that, for Nicolas Flamel, dying
will be a pleasant experience of relief, “like going to bed after
a very, very long day.” Dumbledore’s earlier advice to Harry to
refrain from looking in the Mirror of Erised becomes relevant here,
as Dumbledore suggests that while it is important to reflect on
one’s deepest desire, it is also important to keep that desire in
perspective and perhaps even to limit it. Eternal life—the very
thing promised by the Sorcerer’s Stone and the very thing many have
been desiring—might not be as valuable as those seeking it have
thought. Flamel is close to achieving immortality, and yet he prefers
to die. Dumbledore points out that living forever could actually
become tiresome, and that the desire for it may be misinformed.
While Flamel and Dumbledore ultimately understand that
eternal life may not be such a good goal, Voldemort’s fatal flaw
is that he is misinformed about what is important in life but is
never able to realize it. Voldemort lives for his own desires, but
as we discover toward the end, he is not really living at all: he
does not even have his own body, but must live by stealing others’
bodies (again, one meaning of the French word vol is “theft”). But
Voldemort lacks more than a body; he lacks a soul as well. Living
by desire, he has no real life. Nor does he have any love, as Dumbledore
explains to Harry. Love is the one thing that Voldemort cannot understand,
which is why he is burned by the traces of motherly love on Harry’s
body. The greatest lesson learned throughout this adventure may
be that love for others is more valuable than the pursuit of one’s
own desires (which is really nothing more than love for oneself).
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions | About
©2006 SparkNotes LLC, All Rights Reserved.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||