Important Quotations Explained
1. “I told you the truth,” I say
yet again, “Memory’s truth, because memory has its own special kind.
It selects, eliminates, alters, exaggerates, minimizes, glorifies,
and vilifies also; but in the end it creates its own reality, its heterogeneous
but usually coherent versions of events; and no sane human being
ever trusts someone else’s version more than his own.”
This quotation occurs in Book Two, in
the chapter “At the Pioneer Café.” Saleem has interrupted his story
in order to defend its accuracy to Padma. Throughout his story,
Saleem has appeared anxious about his historical inconsistencies.
He is also acutely aware of how fantastic and far-fetched his narrative
sounds to the skeptical, pragmatic Padma. After he emerges from
his fever-induced dream, it becomes especially important for Saleem
to assert the veracity of his story. For Saleem, everything he says
is true—not necessarily because it happened that way, but because
he remembers it that way. An event from a person’s past gains meaning
for that person’s present existence only when it becomes filtered
through memory and becomes part of the overall story of that person’s
life. Only then can connections be made and conclusions drawn, and
events and instances accrue significance. Saleem has rearranged
history not only because he has forgotten the proper order of events,
but also because by doing so his story gains greater depth and meaning.
Saleem’s rearrangement of facts serves a greater truth as he creates
a new pattern through which to interpret both his own history and that
of India itself.
2. I have been only the humblest
of jugglers-with-facts; and that, in a country where the truth is
what it is instructed to be, reality quite literally ceases to exist,
so that everything becomes possible except what we are told is the
case.
This quotation occurs in Book Two, at
the end of the chapter titled “Jamila Singer.” Reflecting on his
time in Pakistan, Saleem makes an explicit argument against the
strict political control and religious dogmatism of the Pakistani
government. In a nation defined by one official perspective, with
a government that violently rejects any threat to its singularity,
reality cannot exist, since reality is inherently composed of multiple
perspectives. Reality is not just composed of a single truth, as
the repressive rulers of Pakistan would have the people believe.
Lies become necessary to live in a place like Pakistan, in order
to maintain the fiction of singularity. Saleem argues that although
his narrative may play fast and loose with historical facts, his
story is still more truthful and authentic than the Pakistani government’s,
because his tale celebrates and welcomes plurality, a multiplicity
of perspectives, and the possibility of contradiction.
3. Let me state this quite unequivocally:
it is my firm conviction that the hidden purpose of the Indo-Pakistani war
of 1965 was nothing more nor less than the elimination of my benighted
family from the face of the earth.
This quotation occurs in Book Two, in
the chapter “How Saleem Achieved Purity.” Throughout the telling
of his story, Saleem often places himself at the center of major
political events. While we can detect a strain of narcissism in
Saleem’s desire to see himself as either the central cause or primary
victim of various historical events, his life does converge with
national history on countless occasions. If we consider that Saleem—born
at the dawn of India’s independence, and destined to break into
as many pieces as India has citizens—represents the entire population
of India, it makes sense that his life seems directly impacted by
national events. Things that happen on a national or global scale
will always affect the collective life of a nation’s people.
By claiming that the purpose of the Indo-Pakistani war
was to eliminate his family, Saleem draws critical attention to
the fact that the war was justified in religious terms. The Indian
presence in Kashmir was represented as a kind of defilement, and
the Pakistani government claimed that Pakistan needed to reclaim
Kashmir for the good of the country. Saleem claims that he and his
grotesque family also needed to be cleansed in order for the nation
to be purified. The absurdity of Saleem’s claim that an entire war
might be fought in order to murder a family of civilians highlights
the absurdity of Pakistan’s claim.
4. Who what am I? My answer: I am
the sum total of everything that went before me, of all I have been
seen done, , of everything done-to-me.
This quotation appears in Book Three,
at the end of the chapter “Sam and the Tiger.” Saleem has just finished
recalling the rage he felt upon realizing the fundamental unfairness
of life. This passage is a perfect expression of Saleem’s narrative.
He begins his life story thirty-two years before his birth, and
from that moment, considers everything that has happened as being
somehow related to his life. There is a connection between past
and present, between the state and the individual. History is never
past. It plays an active role in shaping the present, and Saleem’s
story is an attempt to capture that dynamic relationship.
5. Futility of statistics: during
1971, ten million refugees fled across the borders of East Pakistan-Bangladesh
into India—but ten million (like all numbers larger than one thousand and
one) refuses to be understood.
This quotation appears in Book Three,
in the chapter “The Buddha.” Saleem, now in the service of the Pakistani
Army, finds himself aiding the violent repression of the Bangladeshi
independence movement. In a novel already riddled with violence
and massive causalities, this is a blunt acknowledgement of the
fact that there is no way to express the scale of violence and suffering
that is occurring. Even Saleem’s first hand account of the atrocities
he witnesses becomes suffused with a sense that what he sees is
incomprehensible. The human mind cannot grasp tragedies of this
scale, and we require a microcosmic representation of the victims—midnight’s children—to
attach individual identities to historical realities. One thousand
and one is the largest number that can be understood, according
to Saleem, and so rather than try and represent the loss of hope
for an entire generation, Rushdie has him offer us the representative
destruction of these children.