|
|
Woman at Point Zero Nawal El Saadawi
Themes, Motifs, and Symbols
Themes
The Connection Between Surveillance and Ownership
Throughout the telling of her story, Firdaus describes the act of
seeing as akin to an act of possession. One of Firdaus's earliest memories
as a child is the memory of her mother's eyes watching her, holding her up
when she struggled to learn how to walk and negotiate the world. For the
young Firdaus, this sense of belonging to her mother and being watched over
by her is very comforting. She feels that being a possession of her mother
is what protects her. Later, though, the act of being surveyed takes on a
very different meaning. When Firdaus grows older, she no longer feels her
mother's eyes supporting her. From then on, whenever Firdaus senses
someone's eyes watching her, she feels threatened. When Firdaus first runs
away from her uncle's house, she encounters a terrifying man who runs his
eyes up and down her body, making Firdaus feel invaded, and as if her body
were not her own.
Firdaus's life-long struggle is to claim her body as her own. When
Firdaus marries Sheikh Mahmoud, his eyes never leave her dish at mealtimes,
and he watches every morsel of food she eats with jealous intensity. Firdaus
becomes self-conscious about eating. Firdaus describes almost all of the men
she encounters in the same waythey rake their eyes over her body and, in
doing so, act as though her body exists only for them. It is not until she
is in prison that Firdaus learns to feel at ease during other people's
examinations of her. This is because Firdaus has proven to herself that she
owns herself and that she is in control of her own destiny.
The Nature of Power
For the young Firdaus, the nature of power seems at first to be very
simple: men have it and women do not. Her father has power over her mother.
Her uncle has power over her. When she is married, Sheikh Mahmoud has power
over her. Even men on the street have power over the women they pass, merely
by turning them into objects with their eyes. Bayoumi, who locks Firdaus in
his apartment and lets his friends have sex with her, has power over her. It
isn't until Firdaus meets Sharifa that her ideas of power begin to change.
Sharifa is a wealthy, independent woman. Rather than allowing men free use
of her body, as married women do, Sharifa uses the power of the desires that
men have for her to her advantage. She teaches Firdaus how to command the
power of her physical appearance. Still, Firdaus doesn't know what it means
to possess power of her own. She learns that women can have power, too, but
she cannot fully wield her own power while living under Sharifa's control.
When she sets out on her own as a prostitute, Firdaus finally learns
what it means to have something that other people desire. This is power. She
learns that she can command higher and higher prices simply by denying
people what they want, or exercising the power that she has over them.
Because of this, she feels that money is power. When she possesses money of
her own, she has power over the people who slander her, and she can give
herself a respectable name by hiring a lawyer and suing. Her brief stint as
an office worker only serves to reinforce this idea, and when she goes back
to prostitution, she charges more money than ever and uses her money to
mingle with more powerful people. Firdaus comes to believe that she has
attained real power. But the pimp who claims her proves that this is not the
case. He threatens to defame her or kill her, proving that no matter how
much money she has, Firdaus is still vulnerable to men because she has
something to lose. When she kills the pimp and later tears up the prince's
money, Firdaus finally proves that she has control over herself.
The Importance of Attaining Respect
Attaining respect does not become one of Firdaus's goals until Di'aa,
who has engaged her services as a prostitute, points out to her that in
spite of her financial security, she is not respectable. Until Firdaus has
money of her own, the way that the world views her never really enters into
her consideration. This is in part because the world has never paid her much
attention before. She was just an invisible person occupying the role of
daughter or wife. When she finally accumulates some wealth and power, the
world takes notice. Men take notice because, in Firdaus's world, men don't
want women to have power over them. By condemning her work as a prostitute
as shameful, they try to minimize her power, though they are also involved
in the exchange of sex and money. For the men in Firdaus's story,
respectable women are women who are submissive and live under the protection
of a powerful man.
When Di'aa tells Firdaus that she is not respectable because the work
she does is shameful, she is deeply hurt. In an effort to become a more
respectable woman, she gives up her nice apartment and prostitution in order
to work in an office. Indeed, she becomes a respectable woman by placing
herself under the power of men again. Firdaus's relationship with Ibrahim is
a part of this quest for respectability. She's playing by the rules and, for
the first time, she feels as though she's met a man she can trust. The
sacrifices she's made to become respectable seem worthwhile. However, when
Firdaus discovers that Ibrahim was using her for sex, she once again
realizes that respectability is a trap that is designed to put women at
the mercy of men. By quitting her job and taking up prostitution again,
Firdaus rejects the pursuit of a respectable life in favor of a life of
power and self-determination. Firdaus has come to see that respectability in
her world means playing by someone else's rules.
Motifs
Sexual Pleasure
During her childhood, Firdaus experiments sexually with a local boy
named Mohammadain. They play bride and bridegroom, meaning that they take
off their clothes and rub against one another. Firdaus describes the
sensation of pleasure she gets from her encounters with Mohammadain, which
end when her mother forces her to undergo a strange surgery. It is not fully
explained in the book, but Firdaus undergoes a clitoridectomy (the removal
of her clitoris). After this procedure, Firdaus never again experiences
sexual pleasure the way she once did. Though her mother forces her to
undergo the procedure as a matter of tradition and doesn't seem to think
about it politically, Firdaus considers the tradition another attempt to
suppress women. By removing the clitoris, sex has become an act in which
only men take pleasure. Firdaus believes that if women were equal to men,
then both would find pleasure in sex.
Pleasure is out of the question in her sexual encounters with her old,
deformed husband. To Firdaus, these encounters are horrific, and she
describes the stench of his open wound and the lack of joy she feels during
sex. She also describes with contempt the way men who come to her as clients
will demand, during sex, to know whether or not she is taking pleasure in
the act. For these men, the act is not about two people enjoying each other,
but instead about proving their physical prowess. They are determined to
wring pleasure from Firdaus, whether she wants it or not. Firdaus tells the
men that she enjoys sex (though she does not), which stops them from asking.
When Firdaus overhears her uncle and his wife having sex, the idea of it
warms her, but she is unable to take pleasure in it herself.
Choice
As a woman from a poor family, Firdaus has never had to make many
choices. Her clitoris is removed and she is married to a tyrannical older
husband without anyone ever asking her opinion. The first real choice she
has ever had to make comes when she flees her husband's home. When Bayoumi
asks her whether she prefers oranges or tangerines, Firdaus is struck by the
fact that nobody has ever asked her to make a decision like that before. She
realizes she does not even know which fruit she prefers, because she has
never had to think about what she wanted. Other people always told her what
would happen. After this, choice becomes an obsession for Firdaus.
As a prostitute, Firdaus has the money and the power to make choices
for herself. She chooses her own apartment and clothing and also begins to
choose which men she will and will not sleep with. Because of this, she
begins to believe in her own independence. The power to choose for herself
is intoxicating. And soon, the fact that she has rejected powerful men makes
her even more alluring to them. By exercising choice, Firdaus commands more
and more money and gets an increasingly prestigious clientele. However, the
pimp who moves in and demands control over her shatters the illusion of
choice for Firdaus. Firdaus realizes that no matter how powerful she might
seem, she is still a woman, and men will still attempt to exercise control
over her. In Firdaus's world, there is no way for her to make real choices.
Though it seems to some that a female prisoner has less power than even the
lowliest wife, Firdaus feels that waiting on death row is the most
liberating thing that has ever happened to her. She chooses not to appeal
her sentence; she would prefer to die in order to escape the control that
other people have over her. Only when dead will Firdaus be free.
Captivity
Firdaus explains that all of her life until the time
she spends in prison has been spent in captivity. Though as a child, a wife,
and a prostitute, she had some degree of physical freedom, she did not
attain mental freedom until she got to prison. Captivity, for Firdaus, means
living under someone else's power. It means not making choices for oneself
and agreeing to be deceived by those in power (whether those in power are
presidents or fathers or husbands). Though Firdaus is waiting to die in
prison, she considers herself freer than anyone else in the world. She
certainly feels freer than Nawal El Saadawi, who hopes to interview her.
Nawal senses this, and it is for this reason that she is so devastated when
Firdaus refuses, time and time again, to be interviewed.
Firdaus looks forward to death because it means that she will have a
chance to start over. Though she is enclosed in a cell, she feels free. She
refuses to work with the system, sign an appeal, or visit with the doctor
because she does not want to feel like a captive. Signing appeals would only
serve to entrap her again, as she would have to appeal to, and thereby
recognize, the power of men. When she finally agrees to meet with Nawal, it
is only in order to spread a message of truth and to do further damage to
the world that abused her before she dies.
Symbols
Money
Firdaus grows up in a poor family in a community of poor families, and
she further recognizes the power of money when she moves to Cairo. As
Firdaus tells it, she never really had money of her own until she started
prostituting herself. Before this, she was at the mercy of her stingy
father, uncle, husband, and Sharifabecause they had money and she did not.
All of them recognized this fact, and they were careful not to give her any
money of her own, lest she escape their grasp. When Firdaus first ventures
out on her ownafter leaving Sharifa's houseand learns that her body has a
monetary value to men, she also learns that she can command more money from
them because she has something they want. To men, her body is a commodity,
just as food and clothing are a commodity: the more difficult it is for them
to obtain, the more money they will pay. In this way, Firdaus begins to
amass money of her own. She despises her work, and she loathes the men who
come to see her, but she greatly values her newfound power. She is not at
the mercy of men anymore.
When she is slandered in public, Firdaus uses her shameful money to
pay a lawyer to clear her name. At this point, money is everything to
Firdaus. It even has the ability to cleanse her public image. But by the
time Firdaus kills the pimp and demands $2,000 from the prince, money has
come to mean something very different. It becomes just another symbol of the
hypocrisy of her society. It gives power to the unworthy and makes the
despicable seem respectable. It allows men to rule over women, and makes the
prince think that he can buy Firdaus. When Firdaus tears up the $2,000, she
demonstrates to the prince that his money has no power over her. Because of
this demonstration, the prince declares that she must really be a
princessi.e., one outside the reach of money's power. Because of Firdaus's
newfound understanding of the treachery of money, the prince is right.
Firdaus is truly outside the reach of money's power.
Books
Firdaus's uncle gives Firdaus her first taste of the power of books
when he secretly teaches her how to read. Books become a symbol of the
kindness of her uncle, who takes an interest in young Firdaus and tries to
teach her. Through reading, Firdaus comes to realize that there is more in
the world than her poor village and humble family. Even before her uncle
teaches her to read, she views the books he brings with him from Cairo as a
kind of passport to a life in which she, too, could be a scholar. When she
moves to Cairo and goes to school, Firdaus spends the few happy years of her
life immersed in books and learning. The time that they spend reading
together is a time of bonding between Firdaus and her uncle.
When her uncle gives up the life of a scholar and marries his boss's
daughter, he sends Firdaus to boarding school. Essentially, her uncle gives
up books in exchange for wealth and status. This feels like a betrayal to
Firdaus, but boarding school proves more advantageous for her than living
with her uncle and aunt. She soon develops a reputation as a bookworm, and
often spends long evenings in the library. She becomes an excellent student
and wins many academic prizes. Books become more important to Firdaus than
people. Yet when Firdaus is married off to Sheikh Mahmoud, books virtually
disappear from her life. Firdaus has to fit herself into the role of
submissive wife, and there is no room for her to be a prize pupil
or a reader. Books, which represented her uncle's kindness and the
potential for a better life, disappear.
  Help |
Feedback |
Make a request |
Report an error |
Send to a friend
|
|