Skip over navigation

Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion

David Hume

Key facts

Part XII

Study Questions

full title  ·  Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion

author  ·  David Hume

philosophical movement  ·  British Empiricism and skepticism concerning the possibility of rational religious beliefs

language  ·  English

time and place written  ·  Hume wrote the Dialogues over a twenty-five year period. The work was largely completed in 1751 while living in Edinburgh. However, because of his fear of the strong religious forces in Britain, he held off publication until after his death in 1776. During the last year of his life, he spent most of his energies preparing the work for publication. He left detailed instructions for the publication in his will.

date of first publication  ·  Although Hume left detailed instructions for publication in his will, these plans fell through. Hume's friend Adam Smith, who was supposed to arrange for the publication, was too afraid to follow through with his role. The book lay dormant for three more years, until Hume's nephew finally arranged for publication in 1779.

speaker  ·  There are three speakers in the Dialogues. There is Demea, the orthodox believer, Cleanthes, the empirical theist, and Philo, the philosophical skeptic. Though Philo is surely the character whose views most closely mirror Hume's own, no one character seems to represent Hume's thoughts entirely.

areas of philosophy covered  ·  The book is primarily concerned with the possibility of natural religion—that is, of the possibility of religious belief based on reason rather than on revelation.

philosophical movements opposed  ·  Hume's primary target in the Dialogues is the empirical theist who believes that there is enough evidence in nature to ground a reasonable belief that God has any particular attributes (i.e. goodness, wisdom, etc.).

other works by hume on similar topics  ·  Hume wrote several works criticizing religious faith during the 1750s. In addition to the Dialogues he also wrote four essays, "Of Miracles", "Of a Particular Providence and of a Future State", "Of Suicide", and "Of the Immortality of the Soul", as well as a book, The Natural History of Religion.

philosophers influenced by the  ·  Philosophy of religion was greatly influenced by Hume's effort. Many later attempts to accuse religious belief of not being grounded in rationality have benefited from Hume's effort. However, fideists and other religious orthodox philosophers have also used Hume's work to support their positions. Perhaps the most famous philosopher who was influenced by Hume's religious ideas was Søren Kierkegaard, the leading fideist of the 19th century.

goal of the book  ·  Hume's intention in the Dialogues is to demonstrate that religious belief has no rational basis.

More Help

Previous Next
Whomever wrote this may very well be Kantian but...

by Bobarooney, May 29, 2014

This chapter is about the Cosmological argument for God's existence, not the Ontological. Of course, Ontological arguments get their name from the term 'ontos' meaning existence, yet it is missleading and potentially detrimental that this is written as though it is about the ontological argument. I've not read the whole thing, though at a glance it is quite obviously mistaken. In short, whomever wrote this cannot have read the 11 paragraphs of Section IX in the DNR.

In truth, the first part of Demea's argument runs closely with Dr Sam... Read more

0 Comments

2 out of 2 people found this helpful

Follow Us