|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Act V, scenes iii–vi
Summary: Act V, scene iii
In his camp, King Richard orders his men to pitch their
tents for the night. He says that they will engage in their great
battle in the -morning. Richard talks to his noblemen, trying to
stir up some enthusiasm, but they are all subdued. Richard, however,
says he has learned that Richmond has only one-third as many fighting
men as he himself does, and he is confident that he can easily win. Summary: Act V, scene iv
Meanwhile, in Richmond’s camp, Richmond tells a messenger
to deliver a secret letter to his stepfather, Lord Stanley, who
is in an outlying camp. Stanley is forced to fight upon Richard’s
side, but Richmond hopes to get some help from him nonetheless. Summary: Act V, scene v
It is now dead midnight.
Cold fearful drops stand on my trembling flesh. What do I fear? Myself? Back in King Richard’s tent, Richard issues commands to
his lieutenants. Because Richard knows of Stanley’s relationship
with Richmond, he is suspicious of Stanley, and is holding Stanley’s
young son, George, hostage. He has an order sent to Lord Stanley
telling him to bring his troops to the main camp before dawn, or
else he will kill George. Declaring that he will eat no supper that
night, Richard then prepares to go to sleep for the night.
Stanley comes secretly to visit Richmond in his tent.
He explains the situation, but promises to help Richmond however
he can. Richmond thanks him and then prepares for sleep.
As both leaders sleep, they begin to dream. A parade
of ghosts—the spirits of everyone whom Richard has murdered—comes
across the stage. First, each ghost stops to speak to Richard. Each
condemns him bitterly for his or her death, tells him that he will
be killed in battle the next morning, and orders him to despair
and die. The ghosts then move away and speak to the sleeping Richmond, telling
him that they are on Richmond’s side and that Richmond will rule
England and be the father of a race of kings. In a similar manner, eleven
ghosts move across the stage: Prince Edward, the dead son of Henry
VI; King Henry VI himself; Richard’s brother Clarence; Rivers, Gray,
and Vaughan; the two young princes, whom Richard had murdered in
the tower; Hastings; Lady Anne, Richard’s former wife; and, finally,
Buckingham.
Terrified, Richard wakes out of his sleep, sweating and
gasping. In an impassioned soliloquy, he searches his soul to try
to find the cause of such a terrible dream. Realizing that he is
a murderer, Richard tries to figure out what he fears. He asks himself
whether he is afraid of himself or whether he loves himself. He
realizes that he doesn’t have any reason to love himself and asks
whether he doesn’t hate himself, instead. For the first time, Richard
is truly terrified.
Ratcliffe comes to Richard’s tent to let him know that
the rooster has crowed and that it is time to prepare for battle.
The shaken Richard tells Ratcliffe of his terrifying dream, but
Ratcliffe dismisses it, telling Richard not to be afraid of shadows
and superstition.
In his camp, Richmond also wakes and tells his advisers
about his dream, which was full of good omens: the ghosts of all
of Richard’s victims have told him that he will have victory. Richmond
gives a stirring pre-battle oration to his soldiers, reminding them
that they are defending their native country from a fearsome tyrant
and murderer. Richmond’s men cheer and head off to battle. Summary: Act V, scene vi
In Richard’s camp, Richard gives his battle speech to
his army, focusing on the raggedness of the rebel forces and their
opposition to himself, the allegedly rightful king. A messenger
then brings the bad news that Stanley has mutinied and refuses to
bring his army. There is not enough time even to execute young Stanley,
for the enemy is already upon them. Richard and his forces head
out to war. Analysis: Act V, scenes iii–vi
These scenes are the psychological high point of the play,
and the turning point at which Richard’s downfall becomes certain.
The play vividly dramatizes the contrast between Richard’s character and
Richmond’s character, shifting its perspective back and forth between
them six times. The leaders, in their respective camps, make almost
identical preparations as they ready for the next day’s battle,
but the difference between them can be seen in the way they go about
their business. Richard speaks brusquely to his lords, and, as we
can see, essentially is isolated from all human contact. As a result
of his malicious nature, he kills anyone who becomes close to him,
gradually destroying all his close human relationships. He is in power,
but he is alone: his brothers, nephews, and even his own wife are
all dead at his hand, his mother has cursed and abandoned him, and
even the person who was once his closest friend—Buckingham—has been
sent to execution.
Richmond, on the other hand, is gracious and friendly
to both his noblemen and his soldiers. The battle speeches of the
two leaders clearly show their different styles: Richmond asks his
men to remember the beauty of the land that they are protecting
from a tyrant, and the wives and children whom they will be making
free. He reminds his men that he himself will die in battle if he
cannot win, and that, if he does succeed, all his soldiers will
be rewarded. In contrast, Richard simply mocks the enemy soldiers,
calling them “a scum of Bretons and base lackey peasants” (V.vi.47).
As Richard says to his noblemen before his speech, he believes that
might makes right, and that “[c]onscience is but a word that cowards
use, / Devised at first to keep the strong in awe” (V.vi.39–40).
Very much Richard’s opposite, Richmond claims to fight for honor,
compassion, and loyalty—in effect, he fights on the side of conscience.
The effect of the ghosts’ procession is something like
having eleven bitter curses (“Despair and die!”) cast upon Richard
in sequence. When Richard wakes, he is shaken by a bout of self-doubt and
soul-searching that is unparalleled in the play, and that many readers
think is one of Shakespeare’s greatest moments of insight into human
psychology. Richard—the two-dimensional villain, the bloody “hell-hound”—is
forced to look into his soul, and is terrified by what he finds
there (IV.iv.48). His uncertainty as to what
he finds within himself, more than the ghosts’ curses, shakes him
to the core.
Sweating and terrified, Richard asks desperately, “What
do I fear? Myself? There’s none else by. / Richard loves Richard;
that is, I am I. / Is there a murderer here? No. Yes, I am” (V.v.136–138). With
this sudden, horrible revelation that there is a murderer in the room,
and that he is it, Richard is suddenly uncertain of whether to be
afraid even of himself. His lines dramatize the realization that
the ghosts have inspired—that he is a dramatically different person
than he has imagined himself to be. He suddenly recognizes that
he is a murderer. His statement “I am I” can be read as an effort
to assert his own self-identity. After Richard realizes that he
has become something that scares even himself, the divide between
who he once was and who he has become is astonishingly clear. This
divide threatens even his existence. Once he realizes that he is
afraid of himself and that he is a murderer, his immediate question
is whether or not he will kill himself. His answer is conflicted.
Although he avoids this possibility by claiming that he loves himself
and therefore would not kill himself, he realizes moments later,
“I rather hate myself / For hateful deeds committed by myself” (V.v.136–144).
In this scene it is very clear that Richard has moved beyond a simple, flat
version of the medieval character, Vice, and experiences the deeply
divided emotions that characterize real human beings.
In a strange, haunting, and even moving conclusion, Richard unexpectedly
turns to thoughts of others, and grieves for his isolation: “I shall
despair. There is no creature loves me, / And if I die no soul will
pity me. / Nay, wherefore should they?—Since that I myself / Find
in myself no pity to myself?” (V.v.154–157).
With these words he realizes, angry and desperate, that he doesn’t
even sympathize with himself. Even after he manages to put aside
his terror and resumes the semblance of his old arrogance, this
sensation does not fade. Clearly, for Richard, the end is near. |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions | About
©2006 SparkNotes LLC, All Rights Reserved.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||