Summary
The narrator—referred to in this SparkNote as the Underground Man—introduces
himself. He describes himself as sick, wicked, and unattractive,
and notes that he has a problem with his liver. He refuses to treat
this ailment out of spite, although he understands that keeping
his problems from doctors does the doctors themselves no harm.
The Underground Man explains that, during his many years
in civil service, he was wicked, but that he considers this wickedness
a kind of compensation for the fact that he never accepted bribes.
He almost immediately revises this claim, however, admitting that
he never achieved genuine wickedness toward his customers, but only managed
to be rude and intimidating as a kind of game.
We learn that the Underground Man has retired early from
his civil service job after inheriting a modest sum of money. He
only held onto his low-ranking job so that he would be able to afford food,
not because he got any satisfaction from it. He notes that he is filled
with conflicting impulses: wickedness, sentimentality, self-loathing,
contempt for others. His intense consciousness of these opposing
elements has paralyzed him. He has settled into his miserable corner
of the world, incapable of wickedness and incapable of action, loathing
himself even as he congratulates himself on his own intelligence
and sensitivity. He adds that the weather in St. Petersburg is probably
bad for his health, but that he will stay there anyway, out of spite.
In a note to Chapter I included in some editions as an
introduction to the novel, Dostoevsky explains his intention in
writing Notes from Underground. He tells us that
the author of the work is fictional, but notes that the nature of
society makes it inevitable that people like this fictional narrator
exist. As to the structure of the novel, Dostoevsky explains that
in the first “fragment,” entitled “Underground,” the Underground
Man introduces himself and explains “why he appeared and had to
appear among us.” The second half, entitled “Apropos of the Wet
Snow,” consists of the Underground Man’s accounts of actual events
in his life.
Analysis
The first chapter of Notes from Underground gives
us a precise sketch of the Underground Man’s character. By the end
of the first paragraph, we get a sense of the issues that preoccupy
the Underground Man. Contradictions and indecision are fundamental
to his character. He says that his liver hurts, but then immediately
tells us that he is not sure it is his liver. He knows he is sick,
but he refuses to see a doctor out of spite, even though he knows
that in pursuing this spiteful behavior he is only in hurting himself.
He develops this idea of indecisive action later in the chapter,
when he talks about the conflicts swarming inside him.
This inability to act stems from several important factors.
First, the Underground Man is a nihilist, which means that he believes that
traditional social values have no foundation in nature, and that human
existence is essentially useless. The Underground Man despises the
society in which he lives. Not only is the weather bad in St. Petersburg,
but the culture of the city is built on bureaucracy and hypocrisy.
Accepting bribes is common and widely tolerated. The Underground
Man is filled with bitterness toward all aspects of society, but
he is aware that he is powerless to act against it or within it. He
cannot even manage to be a wicked civil servant. Instead, he takes
his aggressions out on himself, refusing to see a doctor and remaining
in an unhealthy climate out of spite. This behavior is the first
evidence we have of the Underground Man’s masochism, his enjoyment
of his own pain and humiliation. The Underground Man explores this
idea in more depth later in the novel.
