Quote 5
But
if a dullard should dote, deem it no wonder,
And
through the wiles of a woman be wooed into sorrow,
For
so was Adam by one, when the world began,
And
Solomon by many more, and Samson the mighty—
Delilah
was his doom, and David thereafter
Was beguiled
by Bathsheba, and bore much distress;
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
For
these were proud princes, most prosperous of old,
Past
all lovers lucky, that languished under heaven,
bemused.
And
one and all fell prey
To women they had
used;
If I be led astry,
Methinks
I may be excused.
(2414–2419,
2422–2428)
In this quotation from the end of the
poem, Gawain compares himself to famous biblical figures who were
led astray by the deceitful tricks of women. However, the examples
Gawain names are increasingly dissimilar to him, so that each example
weakens his argument further until it falls apart completely when
he compares himself to David. Eve beguiled Adam into eating from
the Tree of Life in a way similar to the way the host’s wife beguiles
Gawain, but the serpent had already beguiled Eve, which partly excuses
her action—just as Morgan le Faye charmed the host and his lady.
Delilah tricked Samson, but she did so on behalf of her own nation,
and Samson knew he could not trust her. Samson therefore is to blame
in part for Delilah’s betrayal of him. By far, the most clear-cut
of the examples is that of David and Bathsheba. David saw Bathsheba,
whom he knew to be a married woman, bathing on top of her roof and
had her brought to his palace, where he slept with her. She conceived
a child, and David sent her husband, his loyal supporter, out into
the front lines of battle to be killed. As punishment for David’s
sin, God killed their child. Since the men Gawain mentions, David
in particular, are all partly responsible for their own downfalls,
Gawain’s attempt to foist the blame for his sin onto the host’s
wife gains little credence from these biblical examples.
