“I
have only one thing to say to you, sir … if you keep on drinking
rum, the world will soon be quit of a very dirty scoundrel!”
These words, which Dr. Livesey addresses
to Billy Bones in Chapter I, emphasize the conflict between the
civilized world and the lawless criminal world in Treasure
Island. Billy has usurped power for himself, as he refuses
to pay his bills and assumes that everyone will immediately fall
silent whenever he slaps the dining-room table. Billy’s power is,
in fact, quite real: Jim’s innkeeper father is too scared of Billy
to demand payment, and everyone does stop talking when the seaman
slaps the table. Though Billy is a stranger in the area, shows no
special virtues, and has no political or financial power, he nonetheless
holds an extraordinary and mysterious power over everyone. This
power, which Long John Silver also displays, fascinates Jim. Power
of this sort is an insult to the civilized world, as it offends
the values of order, responsibility, and propriety. The practical
Dr. Livesey, who embodies the traditional, ordered world, predicts
that the rum will soon kill Billy and declares that the pirates
are scoundrels. Livesey judges the pirates through the lens of his
own world and its accompanying values. However, by the end of the
novel, we learn that both the doctor’s world and the pirates’ world
are flawed, and that both worlds can inspire and destroy.