Summary: Act V, scene iii
Early in the morning, at the tomb where Hero supposedly
lies buried, Claudio carries out the first part of the punishment
that Leonato has ordered him to perform. Claudio has written an
epitaph, or death poem, celebrating Hero’s innocence and grieving
the slander that (he believes) led to her death. He reads the epitaph
out loud and hangs it upon the tomb. He solemnly promises that he
will come and read it here at this time every year. Everyone then
goes off to prepare for Claudio’s wedding to Leonato’s niece, the
supposed Hero look-alike, which is to occur that very day.
Read a translation of
Act V, scene iii →
Summary: Act V, scene iv
Meanwhile, in the church, Leonato, Antonio, Beatrice,
Benedick, Hero, Margaret, Ursula, and the friar prepare for the
second wedding of Claudio and Hero. We learn from their conversation
that Margaret has been interrogated, and that she is innocent of
conspiring with Borachio and Don John—she never realized that she
was taking part in Don John’s treachery. Benedick is also very relieved that
Don John’s trick has come to light, for now he does not need to fight
his friend Claudio. Quietly, Benedick also takes Leonato aside and
asks him for his permission to marry Beatrice. Don Pedro and Claudio
enter, and Antonio goes off to fetch the masked women. While they
are waiting, Don Pedro and Claudio tease Benedick about his love
for Beatrice and about the fact that he will soon be married, although
they do not know that he actually does plan to be married that very
day. Hero, Beatrice, and the waiting women enter, all wearing masks.
Claudio vows to marry the masked woman by his side, whom he believes
to be Leonato’s mysterious niece. But when Hero takes off her mask,
the shocked Claudio realizes that it really is Hero. Leonato and
Hero tell him that now that Hero’s name has been cleared, she can
figuratively come back to life and be his wife, as she should have
been before.
The party prepares to go to the chapel to finish the
ceremony, but Benedick stops everybody. He asks Beatrice, out loud
and in public, whether she loves him. Beatrice denies it, and Benedick,
in turn, denies loving her. They both agree that they are good friends,
but not in love. But, laughingly, Claudio and Hero tell them that
they know that isn’t the truth—and both whip out scribbled, half-finished
love poems that they have found in their friends’ rooms and pockets,
written from Benedick to Beatrice and from Beatrice to Benedick.
Benedick and Beatrice realize that they have been caught red-handed
and, giving in, finally agree to marry. Benedick silences Beatrice,
for the first time, by kissing her. Claudio and Don Pedro begin
to tease Benedick again, but Benedick laughingly says that he does
not care—he remains determined to be married, and nothing he has
ever said against marriage in the past makes any difference to him
now. He and Claudio assert their friendship again, and Benedick
calls for a dance before the double wedding. Suddenly, a messenger
rushes in to inform the company that Leonato’s men have arrested
Don John in his flight from Mes-sina. They have brought him back
to Messina a prisoner. Benedick instructs Don Pedro to put off thinking
about the villain until tomorrow, when Benedick will invent fine
tortures for him. In the meantime, Benedick insists that all must
dance joyfully in celebrating the marriages, and he commands the
pipers to strike up the music.
Read a translation of
Act V, scene iv →
Analysis: Act V, scenes iii–iv
This final scene brings the play to a joyous conclusion,
drawing it away from the tragedy toward which it had begun to move
and letting everyone wind up safe and sound. Claudio and Hero are
about to be happily married, as are Benedick and Beatrice. The deception has
been revealed, and Don John has been caught and brought to justice.
Everybody has made friends again, and the final dance symbolizes
the restoration of order and happiness in a world that has been
thrown into chaos by Don John’s accusation and Don Pedro and Claudio’s
rash action.
But in order for the play to reach this point, Hero must
go through a symbolic death and rebirth, washing away the taint
of the accusation of her supposed sin. Claudio’s writing and reading
of an epitaph at her tomb seems to create a sense of closure, in
relation to his false accusation of Hero and her supposed death.
He acknowledges his error in having accused Hero: “Done to death
by slanderous tongues / Was the Hero that here lies” (V.iii.3–4).
The song similarly pleads, “Pardon, goddess of the night, / Those
that slew thy virgin knight” (V.iii.12–13).
When dawn arrives at the end of the scene, and Don Pedro says, “Good
morrow, masters, put your torches out,” we can literally see the
plot emerging from darkness (V.iii.24). It
is now time to attend the wedding meant to release Claudio from
his guilt for Hero’s death. From darkness and pain, the story now
returns to daylight and happiness.
The emotional dynamics of the masked wedding must be
complicated, and many readers wonder why Hero still loves Claudio
after what he has done to her. The story can be read as one of real
love that has been tainted by misunderstanding, paranoia, and fear
but that has miraculously ended happily. Hero does seem to love
Claudio still, and they are joyful at being reunited. Claudio’s
amazement, awe, and wonder at finding Hero still alive may serve
to wipe out any last traces of resentment or anger on either side.
